1. I have to be frank about all this bullshit. I am sick and tired of how the media portray individual events and uses them to smear a whole people. All the Mantiqiyyin and Mantiqiyyat are pissed. Yes, it was “an exceedingly bloody crime scene” and indeed it was a horrible murder of a defenseless woman. And yes, we at Mantiq al-Tayr must acknowledge that the two were estranged and that she had hired an attorney and wanted a divorce and was planning to move out soon. Furthermore, she was so disfigured authorities at first couldn’t even tell how she’d been killed. It’s awful and indefensible. Even the killer acknowledges this fact and called it “horrific.”
And there is no doubt that in the aftermath of such a tragedy that everyone would go berserk and portray such a brutal crime in the most damning way possible with respect to the defendant and frankly such a defendant deserves it. But all the hue and cry about this being an honor killing and how the culture of the murderer encourages these things can only lead to hostility and violence against a small minority struggling to make its way in a country whose basic principles it is still trying to come to terms with.
Furthermore, we at Mantiq al-Tayr have been vindicated in our views by the very legal system that is so harassing and besieging the likes of the husband murderer in this case. The time has come for us to eschew the ethnocentric knee-jerk responses to stereotypical phenomena that permeate our consciousness.
It turns out that this woman was wrapping Christmas presents in her kitchen when she was killed. Furthermore she was talking about vacation plans that her husband didn’t like. And she may have had some mental problems that drove her husband to kill her. He just couldn’t control himself. Fortunately the Judge in the case overcame the racist stereotypes in the press and showed mercy on this poor man married to an estranged Christmas-present-wrapping wife with a desire to leave him and who therefore beat her to death with a metal bar while talking to her in the kitchen. Some people probably would have wanted this man sentenced to life in prison or to death. After all, the woman’s brother described her thusly: “She was the most amazing individual, often described as an angel on earth.”
However Mrs. Ellen Robb had the audacity to suffer from some mental problems which bothered her poor, long suffering, Israeli citizen husband, Rafael Robb, and “he just lost it.” Poor baby. The prosecutor too showed sympathy for this poor little tenured professor at the University of Pennsylvania who was born in Israel. “It’s a classic heat-of-passion killing,” said DA Bruce Castor. Judge Paul W. Tressler, and thank G-d we have such insightful judges as he, did not allow passion to overcome his sentencing standards.“This physical bludgeoning is the worst I’ve seen in my entire life,” said Judge Paul Tressler.
“A lot of people failed this woman,” Tressler said. He was blaming the woman’s other family members for her death since they had not sought to have her put into a mental institution which would have prevented her Jewish husband from killing her while she was wrapping Christmas presents.
So Judge Paul Tressler sentenced Rafael Robb to 5 to 10 years in prison including the two years he had already served by the time of sentencing.
“The defendant will receive credit for nearly two years he has already served behind bars. He will be eligible for parole after serving at least five years and was given 10 years probation.”
Thank G-d that Rafael Robb will be out walking the streets by the end of 2011. All he did was beat his wife to death with a metal bar because she was going to leave him and because her mental state caused him annoyance. Women married to Israelis in Pennsylvania should be very afraid.





